Sir Elton John says ‘X Factor is the worst thing to happen to music industry,’ urges new artists to “gig in pubs” to build “real backbone”
In a candid interview with *Rolling Stone*, Sir Elton John opened up about his critical views on the state of the music industry, particularly highlighting the negative influence of talent shows such as *X Factor*. He does not mince words when he states that these platforms, which promise quick fame and success, ultimately harm the artistic growth of new musicians. John believes that artists who seek rapid recognition through these shows often miss out on essential experiences that are vital for their development and durability in the music business.
The Downsides of Talent Competitions
According to John, talent shows like *X Factor* tend to prioritize entertainment over genuine artistry. Instead of nurturing long-term talent, they often create one-hit wonders who struggle to maintain relevance after their initial success. He reminisces about his early career, where he spent countless hours playing in small venues, which he considers an invaluable training ground. The struggle of performing live in pubs and clubs is essential for developing a musician’s skills and fortitude, a lesson that instant fame does not teach.
- John believes that the quick-fix approach of talent shows can lead to unrealistic expectations for aspiring artists.
- He emphasizes that real performance experiences build confidence and stage presence, crucial in a competitive industry.
The Importance of Live Performances
Reflecting on his own journey, John underscores the crucial role that live performances played in shaping his career. He learned the ropes by engaging with audiences, understanding the nuances of stagecraft, and refining his sound over time. This long-term commitment to his craft prepared him for the immense pressures of fame and success. He argues that the lessons learned during those early days of performing before small crowds are irreplaceable, as they cultivate resilience and an authentic connection with the audience.
John also pointed out that the skills required to navigate the music industry often extend beyond mere talent. He articulated that being successful means understanding the dynamics of live performance, engagement with fans, and adapting to varying scenarios. He believes the music landscape is increasingly competitive, and artists lacking this vital experience risk falling short after their initial surge of popularity.
Challenging the Current Music Landscape
In advocating for a shift in focus back to live performances, John encourages new artists to seek opportunities to play in bars and small venues—a practice he believes is essential for developing the emotional depth and artistry needed for a successful career. He calls for a return to authenticity, where artists forge their paths through hard work and dedication rather than seeking shortcuts to fame.
In summary, Sir Elton John firmly believes that the traditional pathway of performing live and building a grassroots following is fundamental for any aspiring musician. While talent shows may offer fleeting fame, they fail to equip artists with the necessary tools to withstand the challenges of a long-term career in the music industry.
For those looking to break into music, John offers a straightforward piece of advice: prioritize building real experience through live performances over the illusory allure of instant fame on television.
